Skip to content

Nut-free bakery · Baked fresh in New York · Ships in one business day

0 items in cart

Cart

Your cart is empty.

NY Cookie Co.

Baked in New York. Devoured everywhere.

Four bakery-counter favorites, 24 cookies to a tin, baked fresh in New York and packed in our signature black tin. Nut-free, and shipped to your door.

  • Nut-free bakery

    No peanuts or tree nuts, so every tin is easy to share at school, the office or the holiday table.

  • Baked fresh, ships in one business day

    Every cookie is baked fresh in New York, packed in our signature black tin and on its way within one business day.

  • Ships across the US

    Tracking on every order, and a gift message for tins sent to someone special.

Choose your tin

24 cookies in every tin. Pick a favorite, or send one of each.

Shop all cookies
  • Chocolate Crinkle cookies beside a black NY Cookie Co. tin

    Bakery Cookies — 24-Cookie Tin

    Price: $44.95
  • Chocolate Crinkle cookies with a powdered-sugar finish beside the black NY Cookie Co. tin

    Chocolate Crinkle Cookies — 24-Cookie Tin

    Price: $44.95
  • Classic Chocolate Chip cookies beside the black NY Cookie Co. tin on a white background

    Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies — 24-Cookie Tin

    Price: $44.95
  • Oatmeal White Chip cookies beside a black NY Cookie Co. tin

    Oatmeal White Chip Cookies — 24-Cookie Tin

    Price: $44.95
Classic Chocolate Chip cookies beside the black NY Cookie Co. tin on a white background

The house favorite

Classic Chocolate Chip Cookies — 24-Cookie Tin

Price: $44.95

The classic. With a New York attitude.Golden chocolate chip cookies with crisp edges, soft centers, and chocolate chips in every bite. The kind you set out with coffee and find yourself reaching for again.Each signature black NY tin holds 24...

Get the tin

Old-school bakery cookies. Very New York about it.

A chocolate chip cookie broken in half over a stack of cookies
  • Baked with the good stuff

    Premium, brand-name ingredients in every batch, because a cookie is only as good as what goes into it.

  • Our signature tin

    Every order arrives in the black NY tin, ready to open or ready to give.

  • Life is sweet, eat it up.

    It's printed on the lid for a reason. These don't last long on the counter.

The gift that gets opened first.

Birthdays, thank-yous, client gifts, or a Tuesday that needs help. Ship 24 cookies in our black NY tin straight to their door, and add a personal gift message in your cart.

Send a tin
Hands passing an open NY Cookie Co. tin of chocolate chip cookies